Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Stone's avatar

Great article, Ross. I really like your writing style.

Expand full comment
eli b.'s avatar

I've just finished reading Simon Balto's book on the Chicago police. The activist demand there, rather than reduction of the size of the police with an eye on abolition, was for a long time for civilian control on the communal level (which of course was promised by the likes of Daly et al but never actually implemented). Given the history, the activist demand has since become committed to abolition. But I wonder if there wouldn't be a constituency for accountability and communal control if anybody ran on it in the mayoral race, which so far nobody is doing.

Otherwise, I don't think that the argument is that the amount of resources spent on the police will necessarily be enough to solve the conditions that incentivize crime to begin with. They are only connected because the police exacerbate such issues and are the wrong tool for dealing with that problem. That said, if they haven't made clear that fiscal ask for social services should not be limited by the size of the police budget per se, then they probably should.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts