Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shep Bostin's avatar

In spite of the negative connotations implied by your article's title (is it snobbery to value artistic expression and intellectual nuance?), I nonetheless think you are very much on track here. Like you, I am decidedly liberal and small-D democratic in the vast majority of my views. But as something of a free speech absolutist, I often find myself at odds with the gatekeepers of "cancel culture" who usually share my other values. Why must we choose between loving art and loving what is popular? Isn't it possible to relish Chopin AND Beyonce? In countless visits to art museums, I have seen many works that I could appreciate artistically, but nonetheless would never have hung in my own home (even if I could have afforded to do so!). This kind of thinking seems very much at the root of the anti-intellectualism discussed in Tom Nichols' excellent book, "The Death of Expertise". In the book, Nichols contemplates how it is that we have evolved a society where so-called "liberal elites" are associated with epistemological pursuits while everyday folks wear anti-intellectualism and even outright ignorance like badges of honor. While his book came out in early 2017, it was based on a long article Nichols wrote in the pre-Trump era. His prescient assessment of a broad trend in society is now a description of how we operate in the U.S. overall. RED = overwhelmingly white, Christian, rural, working class, less educated, more likely to own guns, and so on... BLUE = diverse, secular, urban, intellectual, elitist, etc. Now, we may add to that list, as your article suggests, RED = popular culture and expression filled with "empty calories", while BLUE = artistically meritorious and painfully "politically correct", where all expression must pass through the filters of self-anointed gatekeepers. Why can't I enjoy a Twinkie AND watch an August Wilson play?

Expand full comment
Unset's avatar

“If the only gatekeepers to movie stardom came from Tarantino and Scorsese, I would never have had the opportunity to lead a $400 million plus movie.”

What an idiot. Tarantino has put more nonwhite stars in his movies than I can count offhand.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts