Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Freddie deBoer's avatar

There's another element of the exam school picture that people have to grapple with: when research is done that addresses the selection bias inherent to the admissions system, looking at students just below and above the cut scores, those students go on to identical futures in terms of college and employment. That is, when you look at students who are very similar in educational profiles and chart their paths after some get sorted into the exam schools and some get sorted into regular high schools, they end up just the same. There's no special advantage to attending the exam schools. Of course the outcomes look good, unadjusted, when you're selecting for the highest-performing students. But when you look for advantage that stems from attending the elite schools themselves, it simply makes no difference.

You could use this to say, look, who cares if Asian kids etc. are getting shut out of these schools at higher rates now, they don't matter. But the problem is this: if the advantage is accruing to ability rather than to the school that you go to, then sending less prepared Black and Hispanic kids there won't do them any favors. They'll still have the same level of underlying ability, and that's what's going to determine their success moving forward. It's a shell game.

Expand full comment
Quiara Vasquez's avatar

It's sort of interesting to think about Andrew Yang's mayoral run, and how there were so, so, *so* many thinkpieces about him, and every single one of them had the same comically wrong thesis, which is that Yang may claim to represent Asian Americans, but his pro-cop policies were not aligned with what Asian Americans want. (See Li Zhou in Vox last June, "Andrew Yang and the complexities of representation." Or, like, any lefty mag, which had a piece with this theme.) Which is hilarious, the idea that being pro-cop somehow made Yang *not* representative of the majority of Asian American voters. But the narrative took off!

And it's not hard to see why, because while the majority of Asians in NYC may be pro-cop, the majority of Asians *in media* aren't. Remember that utterly inane "Asians Against Yang" website, in which 900 very online AAPI voters said they didn't like the guy because he was too pro-Israel (LMAO), and how that got plenty of press coverage? There were probably at least 900 Asians who came out in support of Peter Liang back during the Akai Gurley shooting in 2015. Which percent of each of those 900 people do you think are on Twitter?

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts